Why is the government hiding the Harmer Report?
And does anybody really care?
Remember the Harmer Pension Review?
When the Federal Government announced that a wide ranging review into pensions which would ascertain the way forward – providing community feedback on what is fair, what is necessary, and the necessary foundations for future pension planning. Both Debbie and I attended one of the Melbourne meetings where many people offered constructive and passionate pleas for a better deal for single, couple and disabled pensioners. Some people had really struggled to get to this meeting, particularly those using public transport in wheelchairs, or dependent upon the use of walking aids. Other attendees represented associations who have worked long and hard to promote the plight of those single pensioners forced to live on less than $15,000 per annum.
And where did all this feedback go? Into the Harmer Report which was delivered to the Minister, the Hon Jenny Macklin, a few weeks ago.
We asked at the time if the contents would be released and no one in the Minister’s office seemed to know.
So this week we asked again.
And even the spokesperson from Minister Macklin’s office had to admit his answer had a “Hollowmen” ring to it:
1. Yes, the Harmer Report was received by end February
2. Yes, the Federal Government remained committed to pension reform
3. Yes, the Harmer Report would inform pension reform in the May 2009 Budget
4. But no, there was no assurance it would EVER be released!
“Why ever not?” asks AboutSeniors website? Surely in a democracy when you ask the public to make submissions on a form of payment under review – and 1500 submissions are received – it is incumbent upon the government to release the findings for further public debate.
What is there to hide?
We also made contact with the office of the Shadow Minister for Families, Community Services, Indigenous Affairs, the Hon Tony Abbott. A spokesperson said they agreed with our sentiments and will provide a more complete response in next week’s enewsletter.
We are sending a note on this to the Prime Minister and the Opposition Leader and will keep you informed as to why the Pension Review Report cannot be shared with pensioners, taxpayers, and voters who contributed to it.
toot. I am sorry if our light bantering is causing you concern, but quite honestly it is not directed at anyone at all & we are merely trying to keep our heads up by a little lightheartedness. All of us pensioners, whether we are a couple or single, who are living only on the pension are doing it tough, so we realise that you and other widows are also in a lousy place. Our government does not understand what it is like to walk in any of our shoes and we are trying to think of ways to get this across to them. If only we had a pensioner in Parliament then things, I think, could be different. I say could because there never any guarantees in life. So please do not take too much to heart that goes on in this forum. We do however welcome any ideas you might have that could change our position. I hope I speak on behalf of everyone, if not then that is how I see it. It is no joke trying to stretch money until you just can't, but what else can we do at this stage. I am still writing letters, or typing them on the computer as I cannot write for another 4 weeks. The damn surgeon put another plaster on my hand from knuckles to elbow yesterday & said see you in 4 weeks. I was really thinking he would not do that. I cannot drive or do much at all. Living on my own I get into some pickles. I do have a friend who helps, but is not always here when I need help. Oh well, just another problem to add to the list.