Rudd Govt Performance so far.

From Bolt's blog. Thought it worth reprinting here. Thanks to BBP of Omnipresent.


Here’s my list (mostly my own work, but some cut and pastes from other on here too).

1. Grocery Watch
2. Fuel Watch
3. Never taking Japan to Court over whaling as promised. We have now re-issued our threat. Guess when our “deadline” for Japan to stop it is? After the next election.
4. Talking up inflation in early 2008 leading to two rate rises just before the GFC, making it worse.
5. Wasting $900 cheques on dead people and people who live overseas.
6. Unlimited Bank Guarantees freezes people’s cash in non-deposit taking institutions.
7. Stimulus spending totally out of proportion to Australia’s situation during the GFC. Now we are paying for it with rising interest rates. Not to mention taxes will never be cut until the debt is cleared, in say ... 10yrs, 20yrs ? Who knows.
8. Green Loans Scheme shelved and Wong announces an audit into frauds. A tiny number of loans were granted at a cost of how many millions of dollars to set up the scheme?
9. Prior to 2007 he was a “fiscal conservative”. After election and after GFC, he wrote a ludicrous essay claiming that “neo-capitalism” was evil. You can’t have it both ways. If you were a fiscal conservative in 2007, then you were a neo-capitalist too !
10. Pink bats - people die, electrified houses, houses burn down, fake insulations get paid. Garrett demoted after Rudd said he was a “first class minister” and that Rudd would “take responsibility” for the scheme’s failure! No compensation for industry yet.
11. BER - Building the Education Revolution (or Builder’s Early Retirement) fund rorts. Eg. $900,000 for a single new class room. And it was a pre-fabricated.
12. Crazy boat people policy. When Howard left Christmas Island was a ghost town. There are now over 2500 I think. They are building more beds there too, and others have been transported to Villwood and some air force base in the outback.
13. Child care centres at schools broken promise. 38 will be built, not 260.
14. Failed ETS/Copenhagen debacle. 143 were taken to Copenhagen. Count ‘em ... However, as soon as public opinion shifted, the great moral challenge of our time became no urgent problem at all.
15. Promise not to means test the private health insurance rebate broken.
16. Means testing the baby bonus sucks the big one.
17. Promise to “take over” the health system by “mid-2009”
18. New health policy to “stop the blame game” actually means a 60/40 Fed/State funding split and management of hospitals to be by state controlled Local Boards. So when waiting times don’t come down or someone dies because they are sent home early from hospital, does that mean it is because the Feds aren’t putting in enough cash, or the State isn’t? Or is it because the State isn’t properly controlling the Local Boards, or is it because the Local Boards aren’t doing a good job. What a complete joke.
19. Former Defence Minister, Joel Fitzgibbon, basically admitted being bribed by female Chinese government official. Fitzgibbon forced to resign.
20. National Broadband Network. Initial cost was under $10b I think. Now $43b. The only player capable of handling it, Telstra, was rejected, then accepted back, and now is in limbo. The NBN does not have a business plan. That means no one knows whether it will add value to the ecomony, and if it does, no one knows when that might be.
21. Spent the last 10 years criticising Costello’s ability. Then appoints him to control the Future Fund.
22. Tantrums because he doesn’t have a hair dryer or because he got the wrong meal on a plane.
23. Lies about Abbott taking $1b out of health when he was minister.
24. Lies about those boat people who were taken to Indonesia on Oceanic Viking not receiving a “special deal” to get them off the boat. They were all processed in 4wks weren’t they (and granted visas)? What’s the usual timeframe? 3-4 months?
25. He appoints a former Labor member, and family friend, Quentin Bryce, as GG - the most important apolitical, impartial, position in Australia. Then has her travel to Africa to promote his politicial agenda and personal ambitions - 10 nations, 19 day lobbying tour to drum up support for Rudd’s push to gain a non-permanent seat for Australia on the UN Security Council.
26. All time record levels of public debt and annual budget deficits, with the economic wizard, Wayne Swan, in control of managing it.
27. Every primary school child gets a laptop. Bugger all have. And most of them can’t connect to the internet with it.
28. Playing politics with the Henry Tax Review. Not releasing it until very close to the May budget, no doubt in the hope that the Budget news will drown out anything nasty in the HTR.
29. Giving Toyota Aust $15m to help build a hybrid Camry, that even Toyota said they didn’t need because they had already started building it.
30. Industrial laws that prevent teenagers working after school because if they work less than a 3 hour shift, Gillard’s laws say they are being exploited !
31. Industrial laws that give Unions a statutory right to enter any employer’s site. That is, even if the employer owns the land or has a right to exclusive possession, they cannot prevent them from entering. On their own land !
32. Insane levels of expensive trips overseas for the PM.
33. 2020 Summit in Canberra. Countless ideas were produced. PM said everyone of them would be the subject of consideration and a written response by the government. A paltry amount have got their written response - since January 2008. To my knowledge, none of the ideas have been implemented.

FirstPrev12(page 2/2)
26 comments

Every morning I pass a newsstand on the way to work and no matter how early I walk by, there is a chap sitting there selling the papers. And then at night, on the way home, I pass that same newsstand and that same chap is still sitting there, just as he is if I happen to walk past during lunch.



It is this fellow, along with the millions of other working people in this country, who pay the taxes that are being so disgracefully wasted in harebrained schemes of almost nil social utility and zero net value added.



[url=http://www.quadrant.org.au/blogs/qed/2010/04/the-economics-of-rorting]Source[/url]





.

.

.

.

.

.

From Rudd's campaign speech, 2007

Today I am saying loud and clear that this sort of reckless spending must stop. I am determined that any commitments I make are first and foremost economically responsible

For those who think some of us here are judging the imbecile Rudd government too harshly because all politicians make mistakes, I read with interest Laurie Oakes Saturday column where he calls Rudd gutless. Now I dont think anyone would describe Oakes as a biased Liberal, rather another journalist who seeks the truth.



The gutless jibe came about when journalists asked Rudd about scrapping the botched insulation scheme when he was in Tasmania. Rudd simply walked away, while Combet was facing the media in Canberra.



A further example of being 'gutless' in the (non) announcement of scrapping the building of 260 Child Care Centres. Oakes continues that one had to "read a page of waffle" before uncovering the bit that mattered. Another election promise broken or unfulfilled, being covered by spin.



They have made such a historic hash of things thus far how can they be trusted to overhaul the Health and Taxation systems with a credibility of ZERO??

Koko and Tanwinm please keep posting your comments whether cut and paste or your own thoughts, I am always happy to learn from other people. Have you noticed, that those who criticise have no positive comments to make on the subject, just personal attacks on any poster who doesn't agree with them.



I am in absolute dread as to what is going to happen to the health system. There has been no

statement as to what or how things are going to improve and what the cost will be. Just a lot of polly-talk and bribes being handed out left right and centre. Absolutely nothing concrete. I was talking to a member of the Legislative Assembly today and asked him what the deal was with the health system, and he ciould give me nothing of substance. This means that our State premiers and chief ministers have gone along with "pie-in-the sky" talk for the traditional 40 pieces of silver. Heaven help us all.

For those who think some of us here are judging the imbecile Rudd government too harshly because all politicians make mistakes, I read with interest Laurie Oakes Saturday column where he calls Rudd gutless. Now I dont think anyone would describe Oakes as a biased Liberal, rather another journalist who seeks the truth.



The gutless jibe came about when journalists asked Rudd about scrapping the botched insulation scheme when he was in Tasmania. Rudd simply walked away, while Combet was facing the media in Canberra.



A further example of being 'gutless' in the (non) announcement of scrapping the building of 260 Child Care Centres. Oakes continues that one had to "read a page of waffle" before uncovering the bit that mattered. Another election promise broken or unfulfilled, being covered by spin.



They have made such a historic hash of things thus far how can they be trusted to overhaul the Health and Taxation systems with a credibility of ZERO??

Tanwin, yes..I saw that, and indeed gave credit where due on another forum.

One can only hope, that with an election due within months, that commentators and journalists will scrutinise both Liberal and Labor policies with diligence.

Koko and Tanwinm please keep posting your comments whether cut and paste or your own thoughts, I am always happy to learn from other people. Have you noticed, that those who criticise have no positive comments to make on the subject, just personal attacks on any poster who doesn't agree with them.



I am in absolute dread as to what is going to happen to the health system. There has been no

statement as to what or how things are going to improve and what the cost will be. Just a lot of polly-talk and bribes being handed out left right and centre. Absolutely nothing concrete. I was talking to a member of the Legislative Assembly today and asked him what the deal was with the health system, and he ciould give me nothing of substance. This means that our State premiers and chief ministers have gone along with "pie-in-the sky" talk for the traditional 40 pieces of silver. Heaven help us all.

Pommy, the details of the Govt's health policy certainly seem rather vague in some areas.

I was very surprised that Brumby caved in, and wonder now if it was grandstanding on his part.



I think, and would happily be corrected here....that it still needs to go to the Senate.

If that's the case, it's not really a done deal is it?

I think that a little credit is due to Kevin Rudd here. It is easy to

list the things he hasn't done, although very time consuming.

BUT one of the factual based criticisms of every new political Leader

in our brief history, is that they find it necessary to enact all sorts of

new laws, in order to make their mark. It is like the major ability

of all Politicians is to be able to talk for at least an hour without

saying anything. Rudd has not done this. St., Kevin has introduced

a new idiom Ruddism, The ability to be in Government, for the

maximum time, whilst doing nothing & spending the most money

in history, achieving nothing

It is easy to

list the things he hasn’t done, although very time consuming.

True. However I headed the topic as the [i]Rudd Govt's[/i] performance deliberately.

Some of the policies in the list above talk about failed policies...seriously failed policies...not just in terms of financial cost, huge as they are.

This thread is not just an exercise in Rudd bashing. It's hopefully a look at what the Govt has and has not done.



Today, for example, yet another angle on the roof insulation tragic fiasco...and will be the subject of tonight's 4 corners program on the ABC.

Departmental officials behind Labor's botched home insulation program said job creation was more important than safety, a whistleblower has alleged.



The $2.45 billion scheme - linked to four deaths and more than 120 house fires - was dumped on Thursday.



An anonymous Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts insider told ABC TV's Four Corners program - to be aired on Monday - that staff there tried to warn their superiors about the risks posed by the insulation scheme.

[url=http://news.ninemsn.com.au/article.aspx?id=1044708]Source[/url]

.............................

I'll also mention here, yet another boat arrival today....with a reminder of Julia Gillard's words in 2003, then in Opposition.

"Another boat arrival...another policy failure."

.........

And in a similar time period the then Labor opposition described Christmas Island as a white elephant.

This thread is not just an exercise in Rudd bashing. It’s hopefully a look at what the Govt has and has not done.



And the list will get considerably longer as we head to the election, with Rudd's fans in total denial. How long will it take for his Health plan to begin to unravel?

I couldn't think of any Rudd achievements, but I have thought of

one that Howard should have done as soon as he got into

power. Rudd has banned the payment of any commissions

on any financial products recommended by financial advisers.

Definately a very good move.

Quite a few people have been comparing Rudd with Whitlam, and I see now, some of the media are taking this up.

An interesting perspective from Peter Van Onselen:

Rudd is relying on this changed media landscape to get away with his false lines that he backed down on the ETS only because he had no choice in the face of Senate obstructionism, as though somehow section 57, which allows for a double-dissolution election when the Senate twice rejects a bill, has been torn from the Constitution's pages. He is hoping that big news announcements such as tighter smoking laws and Sunday's release of the Henry tax review overshadow his un-Whitlam-like political cowardice on climate change.



The cynical among us may even think the timing of the ETS backdown was designed to be overshadowed by subsequent news items.

[url=http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/opinion/spineless-pm-not-worthy-of-wiping-goughs-shoes/story-e6frg6zo-1225860818596]Source[/url]

Laurie Oakes again has some less than flattering remarks in his Saturday column (which is too long to cut and paste here) on Labor's private polling after Rudd put the ETS on ice-- (no pun intended)



"His credibility has been seriously undermined and the label of political coward has started to stick. Coming on top of other recent backflips and broken promises, shelving a policy so closely tied to the PM looked a lot like panic".



"Convention holds that voters almost always give governments a second term, but ALP realists are starting to see defeat in the looming poll as a real possibility"' [i]Except the Ruddites next door that is.[/i]



And "A prominent Labor figure says Rudd needs to get over the idea that he always knows best and should drop his hostility to those who disagree. He should quickly get some people around him with the guts to tell him when he's wrong" [i]Would you want that job, having abuse screamed at you all day?[/i]



Oakes continues on the ETS, accusing Rudd and Wong of making a hash of selling it. And more damning revelations on the rorts and mis-management of BER which will severely tarnish the reputation of the heir-apparent Gillard.



Rudd is strongly being advised to go to the polls before the Auditor-General, or the task force appointed by Gillard, deliver their reports. Apparently there is a lot more scandal to come out.



Apart from the Labor fans next door I cant recall having read a positive journalists column or letters to the editor on the Rudd government for ages.



So it seems this election will be closer than many had tipped.

Another interesting perspective.



To contemplate the matter before Rudd has faced his first election is truly extraordinary. But it is the question on so many minds. The electoral timidity, the profligacy, the spin, the lack of reason, the internal bullying, the vast waste of money, the interminable photos with children, the transparent use of religion with the photos at church on Sunday, have all embittered his already unimpressed caucus colleagues.

[url=http://http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/opinion/government-without-a-cause-attacking-its-friends/story-e6frg6zo-1225859601078]source[/url]





Gary Johns is a former Minister in the Keating Govt.

FirstPrev12(page 2/2)
26 comments



To make a comment, please register or login

Preview your comment