patronising pensioners

I agree with your suggestion that help being mooted at the moment can be perceived as patronising. Though many people mean well, the idea of being adopted is fraught with potential problems.

For a start, if we, as pensioners, want to live with as much independence and dignity as possible, taking handouts, especially from others who probably can't afford it, is demeaning and embarrassing.

Furthermore, it will only be a matter of time before someone exploits the generosity of the givers, and the whole project will turn sour. This will also turn people against helping pensioners in general.

Some would-be adoptive donors may in their turn exploit the eldferly. The scheme will give them a way in to knowing the living space, the lifestyle, and the finances of pensioners.

My mother, for example, has money lying all over the place. In one room recently I turned up nearly $1,300. She cries poor with us, and we put her groceries on our credit cards; but she's O.K. really. She's exploiting us. But what if someone "adopts" her and offers to tidy up her cupboards? She didn't even know she had that money lying around, and it could easily have been stolen.

One area where I would advocate people parting with cash for pensioners is for their pets. It is heart-breaking when a pensioner has to surrender a much loved animal companion because he/she cannot afford to feed it.

Finally, I am concenred that if the "Adopt a Pensioner" initiative gets too much publicity and is too successful, the Government will sit back and let it happen, without doing what we most want them to do - make the pension a fair and reasonable amount to live on, and, for those of us who can still do some work, increase the amount we can earn before the Government stops our pension & causes much messing around every fortnight.

DELROY OBERG,
42 QUEENSTOWN AVENUE,
BOONDALL, 4034

7 comments

I agree with much of the previous post.

And would add that, cynical though it is, It's a great publicity stunt for the TV channel which started it.

You want to talk about patronising Pensioners read the article in the Sunday Times 8/6/08--then get rid of Noeline Browne- so called Ambassador for the Aging-- who is receiving $2 MiLLION to tell Pensioners to get out and about more and promote health and positive aging. Well that $2 MILLION could have been spent giving more to their weekly allowance so that we can look after our health and wellbeing. And the $2 MILLION was welcomed by the NATIONAL SENIOR, CATHOLIC HEALTH AND AGED CARE ASSOCIATION OF AUSTRALIA---------

WHAT A JOKE ! ! ! !

Not familiar with the Sunday Times Tessatta as it is not a Victorian Paper. Is there a website that would carry the article as it sounds like something we should all read.

It's really not correct to say she is receiving $2 million. Melbourne's Herald Sun has the story see: http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/story/0,21985,23769913-662,00.html

Thank you for that Hughie. It always pays to know what we are talking about before we talk too much and get things wrong :) I like Noelene Brown and hope will be good value and lets face it good on her being able to snazzle a paid position at 69. Maybe 69 is the new 49 now that is a nice thought.

Phyl.

Always help if you are a "failed Labour candidate". The article Tessata mentioned was published 10 days after the Herald Sun article so maybe things have developed since then. Need to read the article before you start knocking Tessata.

I am fairly sure nearly all of us have failed in our lifetimes in something! but most of us go on and get on with what has to be done. Why dwell on one thing but better to remember the good things surely. I wish Nolene Brown great success as I feel she can contribute greatly and many people do not know what is healthy etc. and where to go for help.

I remember so many years ago what was called a "debacle" when Mr. Howard and Mr. Peacock went through the years of "You take the Lead' "No you take the Lead" and the insecurity we all felt with them both............

BUT Mr. Howard bounced back and became our Prime Minister for all the years he was, so love him or dislike him he was voted in, more than once so must have done something right.

I am certainl Mr Rudd will listen so lets hope folk "give him a go" as it has to take a bit of time to settle into any job and I believe he is doing o.k. After all can Seniors blame him for all their woes? The Libs. were in for SO many years and the complaints were thick and fast. I think Mr. Rudd will try and fix what needs fixing given a bit of time.

Phyl.

7 comments



To make a comment, please register or login

Preview your comment