Impurities 'found' in Australian honey

Scientific testing has found that half of the honey sold by Australian supermarkets is adulterated, it has been claimed.

The “fake” honey is a blend of local and imported honeys, which is considered cheating, according to a joint ABC 7.30 Report-Fairfax investigation.

“ASX-listed Capilano's Allowrie-branded Mixed Blossom Honey, which sources honey from Australia and overseas, and markets itself as 100 per cent honey, showed up as ‘adulterated’ in the majority of samples tested,” according to the media probe.

In its defence the honey producer denied its products contained impurities, and questioned the accuracy of the testing – known as nuclear magnetic resolution.

“There is no suggestion that Capilano's eponymous brand of Australian-sourced honey has any issue or that Capilano or other brands were aware of the adulteration.”

However, International Federation of Beekeepers' Association president Phil McCabe believes the test is the most accurate available and thinks consumers are not getting what they paid for.

“By and large [the impurity] is some kind of syrup that's been converted to look like honey, it tastes like honey,” Mr McCabe told the investigation.

“Everything about it seems to be honey, when in fact it's just sugar syrup or something else.”

He said he would refer the tests, commissioned by top law firm King & Wood Mallesons, to Interpol for further investigation.

Germany's Quality Services International lab was commissioned by the law firm on behalf of horticulturalist Robert Costa to conduct two types of tests of the sampled honey.

Supermarket chain, ALDI, has already moved to pull any affected product from its shelves as a precaution.

Do you rely on your honey being 100 per cent Australian? Do you think further testing is required of products being sold by honey manufacturers? Will you be changing the brand of honey you buy following allegations of impurities?

12NextLast(page 1/2)
15 comments

 

I put up a thread about this more than a year ago -- started with Capilano honey and how that was mucked with -- I buy locally grown honey unheated and not mucked with -- we have to be sure to read all the small print and BUY AUSSIE -- in all things --  not just MADE in AUSSIE BUT MADE OWNED AND GROWN here if    it states it is made here that means it could be grown and IMPORTED for God knows where.

We must insist on it as if we don't we will be a 3rd world country in no time

Also not only HONEY but everything

PlanB - My son lives in the north-west of Sydney. He buys his honey from a lovely old man who sits

on the side of the road with a little make-shift stall. He also sells the best Strawberries and

watermelon. As you say - BUY AUSSIE>

I agree with PlanB.  

I only buy honey direct from the growers at markets.  Much of the supermarket honey is mixed with foreign (Chinese) honey which is not necessarily all honey - it is a sugar syrup substitute.  Also, much of this honey is pasteurised, increasing the temperature to over 60 Deg Celsius and thus killing all good bacteria and microbes.  

Same with fruit and Veggies - how do you think apples etc can come from the US via a ship and still have the goodness in them.  And don't mention garlic from China - soaked in poison!

Thank you Mindy you are so right,  

I was always brought up to eat in season and FRESH as --- in those days it was easy because there was none of this importation and freezing fruit and such -- AND it tasted so much different to what rubbish we buy these days -- I have an Apple sitting on the bench uncut and I am waiting to see how long it lasts -- it has been there for 6 weeks now and still not rotten -- I am wondering how long it will last --- I guarantee it would have NO goodness in it though.

I ask you what the hell are they doing to our food!?

I will then take it back to Woolies and tell them the date I bought it and ask for an explanation.

A man named Simon Mulvany exposed this years ago & has been battling Capilano and Kerry Stokes ever since .....

https://www.beethecure.com.au/capilano-vs-savethebees/

Honey is mixed to give a constant flavour but I never knew any of the product was mixed with syrup.  That would be illegal under labelling laws and I'm sure not even a conflicted government would allow this to go by.  Maybe I am wrong though.

I blame Malcolm Turbull eh MICK.

Where I live in Australia, " Mildura - Voctoria " fortunately there are a few local apiarists / stockists who are easily found & ( the real local stuff ) can be bought from them quite easily. 1.5 kg of real honey may cost roughly $30, but that dosh is terrific value as the 1.5 kg lasts abouts 6 months. If my math is correct,  $30 divided by 26 weeks, umm, that's $1.15c a week

I really don't see the point whatsoever of paying outrageously, exhorbitant " food mile "  supermarket prices; when we all know these duopolists fleece not only us shoppers, but also demand suppliers to " rent shelve space '.  Cheapest being the bottom & top rungs. Hey Primary Producer/Supplier, you want eye/shoulder level?  That'll be $$$$$$$$$$$$$ for 2 weeks max!

Thank goodness for " Certified Farmers Markets "!  Reasonable prices, $50 virtually fills your  large reusable tote bag, you directly know whom your supporting & it all comes with a beaut smile, usage pointers & great conversation if you hang around a bit.  Nuttin better!!

I purchase my honey directly from the manufacturer - Beechworth Honey, which is a short drive from where I live.  It may cost me more to buy direct, but at least I know it's pure and not adulterated.

I like Beechworth honey too. Luckily for me, my local Woolies stocks it.

Do you rely on your honey being 100 per cent Australian?

-YES!-

Do you think further testing is required of products being sold by honey manufacturers?

-YES!-

Will you be changing the brand of honey you buy following allegations of impurities?

-ABSOLUTELY-YES!-

Checking my honey jar bought recently from Coles I read the label, Coles brand:  "Pure Australian Honey"

Ingredients: "Australian Honey"

But, is it? Is it 100% Australian honey? It doesn't clarify that.


I buy Nothing that has a Coles or a Woolies label on it as it can be packed here but can be imported from anywhere and you can be darn sure that they -- Coles & Woolies --would be getting the cheapest and making the BIGGEST profit.

So much Honey is mucked with by China and they have NO morals at all

I don’t buy anything that says “Australian Owned”.  Australian Owned doesn’t tell me where their company/factory is.

Well said PlanB, have to agree with you.

 

Agree with you, HS, as well as with PlanB.

The food labelling is seriously deficient and is partly to blame for such fraud to occur - if it says 30% Australian ingredients, WHERE is the REST FROM? - that's what we need to know! Many of us try to buy Australian, however the Govt and it's agencies / bureaucrats refuse to give us the full information - even if we want to avoid Chinese products we can't seem to avoid it as in this case. Disgusting failure of Labelling and lack of enforcement of truth in reporting.

This is one reason to distrust some of our suppliers.    I take the time to do lots of research when I buy a product....the only way is to buy local honey from your farmers markets or our most reputable honey Beechworth.     There are also some great honey producers in Tasmania and their products are available online.

Yes please everyone please buy nothing but Aussie Grown Packed and made -- let all the otherubbish sit on the shelves --

 

No point having free trade deals if everyone buys only Australian. We need competition. No competition, less profit, less money for pensioners ad infrastructure. Ask olbaid.

We buy New Zealand honey.

Yep Reagan the Mauka honey from NZ is great. It's even used in some hospitals for its healing properties.

must be a new type of honey that Mauka

 

Captain Cook was the first white person to taste Manuka honey.

 

Are you aware Reagan that NZ  -- is allowed to IMPORT anything they like and relabel it as from NZ? 

I used to think years ago that NZ stuff had to be good --- WRONG  -- it could be from anywhere -- and IMO this is so darn wrong for them to be able to do this --- so beacuse of that I buy NOTHING from NZ now.

We also have very good Manuka Honey here as well as we have the same tea Tree it is made from --Leptospermum scoparium

We never used to have trade deals and we were far better off then and had lots of jobs too and lots of manufacturing-- 

We have to become self-sufficient again as what happens when the  S--t hits the fan and those places refuse to do the right thing?     

We have to think ahead

So you think Australia should become an autarky? International trade is as old as the hills..not sure of the date but would guess some 3000 years ago people began trading with nearby countries.

No country is self-sufficient..that’s why we have trade. The only country to my knowledge that comes really close is North Korea..they focus on self reliance at the expense of their people. However..even they have to trade with China as they don’t have enough petroleum, coal, textiles and machinery of their own. In return.. North Korea supplies China with other natural resources it has a lot of such as iron..

Australia is not self-sufficient because it relies significantly on other countries to provide critical resources like petroleum, vehicles, telecommunications equipment, computers and medications. If one is talking only in terms of food..then if there is a global trade collapse..I believe we could manage..although we’d have to contend with drought and we know what that means. Shortages..high prices..yes and even increased poverty..

If Australia was to become self sufficient..we’d have to regress technologically..yes back to the dark ages or are we willing to be like Costa Rica and rely solely on renewable energy? I know I am..I think Australia can become entirely self sufficient if we invest in wind power, solar panel, geothermal energy and hydroelectric power. But all that comes at a cost..are you willing to pay for it?

Something to consider..the world’s natural resources are spread unevenly across the planet..so..it makes sense to benefit each other by being open to trade..



Sophie, I realize that we are not able to be fully self-sufficient BUT we used to have way more manufacturing etc yes we still imported some stuff -- and we will always have to but NOT to the extent we are now -- If we have it here and are able to buy it here grown here then why wouldn't you support your own country?

Some people buy stuff because of the price may be cheaper -- but I ask at what cost in the long run --plus you have no idea if such are even safe -- as it has been proved time and again

It is a lot like being personally self-sufficient -- always better rather than have to rely on others do you not agree?


"Are you aware Reagan that NZ  -- is allowed to IMPORT anything they like and relabel it as from NZ? "

you don't say!

 

Australian manuka honey is made by capilano, that's why I get mine direct from NZ

Honey is bee vomit 

Olbaid- You regurgitate facts, but they are not sweet -

ROFLMAO

Tasmanian honey is superb & very pure. There are several brands & some is sold at markets.

NZ is trying to take away the Melaleuca label & patent it. It was first produced in Tasmania & is an ex

celent product which is consumed locally & exported.

Yes, Polly,  Tassie stuff is always great --

 

Isn't Australia one of, if not the largest, of the world's honey producers?

The federal government knew about honey substitution with glucose when I was in early employment.  I would like that question to be addressed to the federal DPI and State departments of Primary Industry, which would doubtless prove that BOTH sides of politics and those minor parties over the years were all aware, or should have been aware, of honey substitution.  -Just as there was substitution of milk, of meats (remember the Royal Commission meat substitution report?) and other products.

What is happening here is that local and foreign interests are takning advantage of farmers and the public, as per usual.  Are there no investigative reporters, or is personality politics, the second national game ('dissing' men is the No1 national game it appears) easier chaff for reporters nd editors?

Yes LJ,  it is the people that have to stay awake to whats going on --people have short memories and thats what so many rely on

12NextLast(page 1/2)
15 comments



To make a comment, please register or login

Preview your comment