Government Report Card
A recent Government Report Card survey conducted by the [b]About Seniors[/b] website reveals a deep-seated dissatisfaction with the federal government. More than 300 respondents answered 13 questions online about the Rudd Government’s performance. The answers were not good news for a government which is hoping to be re - elected later this year.
[b]Demographic Information of Respondents[/b]
[b]Gender[/b]
Male: 65.42%
Female: 34.58%
[b]Age[/b]
Under 45: 1.87%
45-54: 3.12%
55-64: 31.46%
65-70: 33.64%
70+: 29.91%
[b]Results[/b]
[b]Q1. [/b]Despite the financial crisis, has the Rudd Government managed to keep the economy on track?
Yes: 45.66%
No: 54.34%
[b]Q2. [/b]Should the Henry report on taxation be released or is it reasonable to hold it until after the May budget or an election is called?
It should be released before the May budget: 83.33%
It is reasonable to hold off until after the May budget: 12.50%
It is reasonable to hold off until after an election is called: 4.17%
[b]Q3. [/b]Do the health reforms go far enough to reduce waiting lists?
Yes: 16.61%
No: 83.39%
[b]Q4. [/b]Is the extra money promised by Prime Minister Rudd just a sweetener to get the health reforms through?
Yes: 83.17%
No: 16.83%
[b]Q5. [/b]Dental health – has anything been done?
Yes: 9.77%
No: 90.23%
[b]Q6. [/b]Do we need an Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS)?
Yes: 30.72%
No: 69.28%
[b]Q7. [/b]Have the recent government grants gone far enough to help households cut greenhouse emissions?
Yes: 26.73%
No: 73.27%
[b]Q8. [/b]Has the National Rental Affordability Scheme really helped with rent affordability for most Australians?
Yes: 18.73%
No: 81.27%
[b]Q9. [/b]Has the Rudd Government delivered on its promises?
Yes: 19.67%
No: 80.33%
[b]Q10. [/b]Is this enough?
Yes: 11.48%
No: 88.52%
[b]Q11. [/b]Who will you vote for?
Labor: 21.26 %
Liberal-National Party Coalition: 49.50 %
Greens: 2.66 %
Independent: 4.65 %
Other: 1.66 %
Undecided: 20.27 %
[b]Q12. [/b]Who is your preferred Prime Minister?
Kevin Rudd: 34.97%
Tony Abbott: 65.03%
[b]Q13. [/b]Who is your preferred treasurer?
Wayne Swan: 36.84%
Joe Hockey: 63.16%
[b]About Seniors[/b] received a number of emails regarding the Hon Bronwyn Bishop MP accepting our invitation to reply to the above poll. In a separate email to all members of both the House of Representatives and the Senate we invited all current members of parliament to share their ongoing views only heard back from the Hon Bronwyn Bishop MP. You can view her response here: http://www.aboutseniors.com.au/index.php/articles/category/government_report_card_2010#do_politicians_care_what_you_think
In reply to the article, we have listed a few of the emails below:
"Hello, About Seniors
Even if only Bronny replied to your request, I hope you’ll preserve political balance by seeking out a government response."
"Can you tell us why you would ask Hon Bronwyn Bishop MP to tell us how the Rudd Government is going.
She is a Liberal did you really think she would give the Rudd Government a glowing report ."
"How biased can you get > the statistical sample number of 300 given is
totally skewed/inadequate.
Not a "representative sample" of the socio/economic spectrum for this age
group!!!.
Many of my generation do not possess or can operate computers and
subsequently receive regular email newsletter/s.
I happen to be 71 years old and have been computer "literate" since the
first mainframes were introduced in the mid 1960's.
Please remove me from your mailing list."
"Dear Editor
I was very disappointed with your rubbishing of the Govt in the May 28 Newsletter. Having conducted many surveys as an academic I see many questions were clearly not meant to be neutral but to draw negative responses, aimed especially at getting votes from those who are critical of the Govt.
As far as Senator Bishop's response is concerned it was what would be expected of any Opposition member & anyone would anticipate her answers. I write to the Govt periodically on age pension matters & I find I always get a response, although it usually does not come quickly - not surprising , given the quantity of mail Ministers would receive as well as their duties as Govt, unlike the Opposition whose main task seems to be to oppose & criticise all Govt actions but still cannot put forward better alternative policies. Pensions were reduced in real terms while they governed, even after there were budget surpluses, so I am sceptical that they would be better next time. And they removed support for dental care also.
The survey's responses are so dramatically different to the various published polls that I wonder how representative are the people who took part. Unless polls are conducted by experienced professionals with no axe to grind, the questions often determine the result, especially when there is no sound methodical choice of respondents. Political parties are known to organise multiple responses to online & phone surveys in order to get results that convince readers that everyone agrees with them - hence the results often are opposite to those polls conducted using sound survey methodology.
I hope you will seriously consider these comments & get professioal assistance before attempting future polls, especially anything political, so as to provide balanced information for your readers. I take it you will print the Govt response if & when that comes.
There is plenty of room for additional support for Seniors & I hope you can contribute positively towards debate that can improve policies by all political parties. Polls that seek positive input for better policies would do more for Seniors. The poll & comments sound too much like a part of the Opposition election strategy."
"Hi,
It appears to me that a group such as Seniors should be using the power of the people to influence political thinking and law making - especially as we will be a major demographic in coming years.
As individuals we have very little influence, and in fact are probably ignored to a large extent.
For example, surveys show that over 80% of the population support voluntary euthanasia, whereas almost all politicians vote with their feet on the issue and make themselves scarce. This is because they fear the religious groups and because they see few votes in the topic. However, if a group such as About Seniors were to take up the cause, maybe that 80% could start having more impact on the debate.
I have waited a lifetime for progress in this area, and it shows no sign of arriving in time for my own end, which is both sad and criminal. I would rather my cat's legal rights than my own in this regard!
Surely groups with influence should be going in to bat on our behalf, and giving us all the right to die with some dignity rather than being forced to accept the myth of universal palliation.
The right to die will not be given to us without pressure being brought to bear on our politicians - not just once, but continuously until real progress is made.
I'm probably wasting my breath - but this is an issue worth fighting for - for all of us."