Do we need truth in political advertising?

A petition calling for an inquiry into political advertising is taking off following a federal election marred by deceptive political advertisements.

Kate Johnson who started the petition said the issue should have bi-partisan support to clean up politics before it was too late.

“The recent federal election was marred by frankly misleading and deceptive advertising, with the Australian Electoral Commission powerless to act. Clive Palmer spent $60 million dollars on advertising to undermine Labor’s campaign. Whilst Adrian Kelly, president of the Real Estate Institute of Australia, mislead the Australian public by claiming that Labor’s policies on negative gearing and capital gains tax would reduce property prices and increase rent, claims that are not substantiated by economic modelling,” Ms Johnson wrote.

“Another incident saw signs resembling official AEC signs directing Chinese voters to vote Liberal. Whilst claims that Labor would introduce a death and inheritance tax proliferated on social media and were amplified by the major parties.

“Make no mistake. This should be a bipartisan issue. Both parties ‘play dirty’ and do ‘creative calculations’ at elections. Labor was caught saying the LNP would cut funds to public schools, when in fact they merely promised to spend less than Labor did.

“While less than ideal, the issue of spreading misinformation and manipulation of the public by vested interests is growing and will become a problem larger than the major parties. We live in a time when there is an unprecedented capacity to target the electorate through social media and mobile phones. If we want to safeguard our democracy, we need to act now.

“The Australian people deserve the opportunity to make genuinely informed decisions about their representation in government and should not be manipulated by wealthy special interest groups. We call for a government inquiry into how truth in political advertising laws could be implemented. The integrity of our democracy and the faith of the Australian people depends upon it.”

You can sign the petition here.

What do you think? Should there be more done to stop politicians telling porkies at election time?

12NextLast(page 1/2)
23 comments

We could use honesty and integrity full stop.

Competition and ignorance can make that seem a fair way away.

When my eldest would try to put one over me, somehow it was always obvious. A moment of quiet and he would ask how I knew. Then procede to give not only the truth but the whole truth knowing the original deceit would then be instantly forgotten. All parents would have similar, hopefully not too many, experiences. Perhaps we just need to find a way of recognising a range of different bovine faeces as spewed from a range of different attempted dodgers. 

A couple of notable (dodgy) politicians and would-be politicians don't seem too hard to sum up in a non "fake" way. 

 

We could use honesty and integrity full stop.

Competition and ignorance can make that seem a fair way away.

When my eldest would try to put one over me, somehow it was always obvious. A moment of quiet and he would ask how I knew. Then procede to give not only the truth but the whole truth knowing the original deceit would then be instantly forgotten. All parents would have similar, hopefully not too many, experiences. Perhaps we just need to find a way of recognising a range of different bovine faeces as spewed from a range of different attempted dodgers. 

A couple of notable (dodgy) politicians and would-be politicians don't seem too hard to sum up in a non "fake" way. 

 

 "Stop politicians telling porkies at election time?

I thought it was a pre-requisite for their job.

We should instead ban mandatory voting - then we wouldnt need to worry so much as those who cant be bothered to follow politics wont be mislead by the usual stuff these elections spew. 

One thing that came out of this election is majority of voters are NOT as dim as many try to tell us. 

What about the *Starship Voyager Challenge: truth in the media?

*Starship Voyager Challenger - to go where no journalist has gone before and somehow find the truth.  Yeah, I know, an outrageous proposition.

"Should there be more done to stop politicians telling porkies at election time?"

Why focus on only 6 weeks of the years?

This government got in because the way the papers were done -- the way Clive Palmer spent so much and also had the Libs on his paper and the Libs had Clive on their paper -- Clive did a crooked thing because he wanted to get coal mines in QLD and the Libs knew they would get votes through him.             

The WHOLE election was a downright corrupt affair  --- even Morrison was very surprised as were everyone else -- Clive Palmer might be corrupt but he is NOT stupid

NOT stupid until one gets caught out...then one becomes stupid...

Tony Abbotts promise on the eve of the 2013 election “.....no changes to pensions.....” disgraceful.

"no changes to pensions...in the first term of the government"....is what he said...GET IT RIGHT PEOPLE!!!!!!!!!!

Oh yes, Mad as Hell,    Abbott broke every promise he ever made -- and he professes to be a  CHRISTIAN? 

Seems there are a LOT of so-called Christians that do some mighty un-Christian things


tis 2019 now if you didn't realise :-)) so one might now be asking who or who was Tony Abbott? and why does 2013 matter? any more :-))

“... no changes to pensions......” guess that was a non core promise.

It’s been almost 18 months since the 2017 changes to the Pensioner Assets Test with 330000 part pensioners having $750 million of their assets stolen for the budget emergency.

Thats $2.5 billion stolen over five years and now the LNP have to stimulate the economy over the next 10 years by forgoing $158 billion in taxes. It’s a non sequitur.

Breaking election promises, stealing from pensioners and then Joe Hockey and Mathias Corman celebrating with stogies is not a good look or advertisement for the LNP

Truth and politics! an unlikely combination. There never was and never will be truth by those in or those who seek power.

The only chance we have is to have a Genuine reporting media and journalist who are able to expose the "truth" without fear of being hounded by the gov. for any exposure.

And we need real transparency from govs. not hiding behind all sorts of coverups and "commercial in confidence" shams.

As  Plan B said, the whole thing is corrupt, instigated by the bloody stupid preferences system. It's about time the government did away with this ridiculous scheming corrupt system, which is not fair at all on a candidate, who expects to gwet elected on his own meritm but it will never happen while we have this Hare Clark corrupt system in place; and also mandatory voting, ---- true democracy !!!!   There is onlyone person a politician is interested in , and that's number one. To get elected by fair means or foul , as seen telling voters in Chinese who to vote for. Are they allowed to vote, under the immigration act, I'm sure many of them arrived post 1983.

As  Plan B said, the whole thing is corrupt, instigated by the bloody stupid preferences system. It's about time the government did away with this ridiculous scheming corrupt system, which is not fair at all on a candidate, who expects to gwet elected on his own meritm but it will never happen while we have this Hare Clark corrupt system in place; and also mandatory voting, ---- true democracy !!!!   There is onlyone person a politician is interested in , and that's number one. To get elected by fair means or foul , as seen telling voters in Chinese who to vote for. Are they allowed to vote, under the immigration act, I'm sure many of them arrived post 1983.

Truth in Advertising should cover ALL advertisements not just the Pollies. All advertising material must be in the English Language regardless of where in the Country a person lives. If you live in Australia you should be reading and writing English so there is NO NEED for other languages on Advertising full stop!

All sides of politics lie to gain votes, that is a given. We can single out incidents that show up what one side or the other has said but the truth remains that it is rife. We need truth in advertising laws to be extended to include political advertising which has been made exempt but I'm not standing one one leg waiting for politicians to change anything.

The media is another story. They tell the truth but not the whole truth and in so doing can mislead the readers by leaving out pertinent facts that give the whole picture. The media at present is on a crusade to stop the AFP from doing its job of trying to find out who is leaking confidential documents. They are telling only their side of the story which gives an impression that the AFP is after reporters and is trying to shut down freedom of the press when nothing could be further from the truth.

It's disgusting that politicians are allowed to lie and wage theft billionaires are allowed to stand for parliament.

A Prime Minister was elected because he paid for the PR Team of Hill Douglas to change his identity. They changed his name to ScoMo gave him a whole lot of meaningless slogans to use on his campaign. It worked. The Australian public is so gullible.

Yes everyone wanted a go! ha ha

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5c_UO5PCklY

How good's ScoMo?

Really jackie, your one-eyed view of politics is getting a bit too much. Not a word from you about millionaire Rudd being elected, not a word about millionaire Garrett being elected so I suppose millionaires are OK but they had better not be more successful than just millionaire status. 

Australians are not gullible, they voted for a tax cut, not a tax increase. No PR teams could have changed those polar opposite ideals. They did as they were asked to by Bowen; "If you don't like Labor's policies, don't vote for them!" 

Old Man, very well put. I may add.. Scott Morrison was also the people's choice because he appeared to be his natural self. Conversely, the vast majority of voters rejected Bill Shorten because of a perception of insincerity. How could so many get that so wrong? 

12NextLast(page 1/2)
23 comments



To make a comment, please register or login

Preview your comment